Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Gator vs High Lift Mower Blades: Which One Should You Buy?

Gator blades and high lift blades compared on mulching, lift, deck fit and mounting, with 22 inch, 42 inch and 60 inch examples from the listings.

Gator vs High Lift Mower Blades: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1UDC Parts 42 Inch High Lift Mulching Blades 2-PackUDC Parts 42 Inch High Lift Mulching Blades 2-Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2UDC Parts Toro 22 Inch Gator Mulching Blades 2-PackUDC Parts Toro 22 Inch Gator Mulching Blades 2-Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3BCQNXX 60 Inch High Lift Mower Blades 3-PackBCQNXX 60 Inch High Lift Mower Blades 3-Pack9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Oregon Gator G3 22 Inch Mulching BladeOregon Gator G3 22 Inch Mulching Blade9.4/10View on Amazon

Verdict: Choose gator blades if you mulch and want clippings recut fine under the deck. Choose high lift blades if you want strong lift that moves clippings up and out, and your deck and center hole match.

After a wet week the lawn stands tall and thick, and the mower leaves clumps and stragglers behind when the blade under the deck is wrong for the job. The gator vs high lift mower blades question comes down to what should happen to clippings after the cut: recut fine and dropped, or lifted hard and moved out. This comparison covers the differences, then the examples from the listings.

AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.

The examples

UDC Parts 42 Inch High Lift Mulching Blades 2-Pack

UDC Parts 42 Inch High Lift Mulching Blades 2-Pack

UDC Parts9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A 2-pack of high lift mulching blades for 42 inch decks, 6-point star center hole, 21-1/4 inch length, 1-7/64 inch air lift and 6-57/64 inch cutting edge.

Who it's for: owners of 42 inch mowers on the fit list.

Who should skip it: anyone whose mower takes a round center hole instead of the 6-point star.

The UDC high lift set fits 42 inch Cub Cadet, Craftsman and Troy-Bilt decks with a 6-point star center hole, and the listing warns that other patterns will not fit. Length is 21-1/4 inch, width 2-1/2 inch, air lift 1-7/64 inch and cutting edge 6-57/64 inch. Parts differ between configurations of the same model, so the complete model number matters.

Pros

  • Two blades in the pack
  • 6-point star mounting for the listed Cub Cadet, Craftsman and Troy-Bilt fits
  • 1-7/64 inch air lift, the highest lift figure among the examples
  • Pre-sharpened edge that can be resharpened

Cons

  • Only the 6-point star pattern; other patterns will not fit
  • No weight stated on the listing
  • No thickness stated on the listing
  • Verify the complete model number before ordering
UDC Parts Toro 22 Inch Gator Mulching Blades 2-Pack

UDC Parts Toro 22 Inch Gator Mulching Blades 2-Pack

UDC Parts9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A 2-pack of gator mulching blades for 22 inch Toro Recycler decks, 21-11/16 inch long, 29/32 inch air lift and 5-3/64 inch cutting edge.

Who it's for: owners of 22 inch Toro Recycler or Lawn-Boy mowers on the fit list who mulch.

Who should skip it: anyone whose center hole differs from the stated 7/16 inch round hole.

The UDC gator set replaces Toro 131-4547-03 and related part numbers for 22 inch Recycler decks, with a 21-11/16 inch length, 2-1/2 inch width, 29/32 inch air lift and 5-3/64 inch cutting edge. The blades are pre-sharpened high-strength steel, the edge can be resharpened, and the listing gives 1-year product support for manufacturing defects.

Pros

  • Two blades in the pack
  • Long fit list across Toro Recycler and Lawn-Boy models
  • Pre-sharpened edge that can be resharpened
  • 1-year product support for manufacturing defects

Cons

  • No weight stated on the listing
  • No thickness stated on the listing
  • Gator teeth suit mulching; no bagging claim stated
  • Cutting edge of 5-3/64 inch is the smallest edge among the examples
BCQNXX 60 Inch High Lift Mower Blades 3-Pack

BCQNXX 60 Inch High Lift Mower Blades 3-Pack

BCQNXX9.5/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A 3-pack of high lift blades for 60 inch decks, 20-1/2 inch long, 2-1/2 inch wide, 0.240 inch thick, 5/8 inch center hole, 29/32 inch air lift and 7-1/16 inch cutting edge.

Who it's for: owners of 60 inch decks on the fit list who need a full 3-blade set.

Who should skip it: anyone with a smaller deck or a different center hole.

The bullets state 20-1/2 inch length, 2-1/2 inch width, 0.240 inch thickness, 5/8 inch center hole, 29/32 inch air lift and 7-1/16 inch cutting edge for a 3-pack on 60 inch decks, while the spec table lists 10.0 inch dimensions and 1 item. Trust the bullets over the spec table: the fit list names Bad Boy, Exmark, Gravely, Hustler and Toro models. The listing advises periodic inspection and replacement as blades dull.

Pros

  • Three blades in the pack
  • 7-1/16 inch cutting edge, the longest edge among the examples
  • Wide fit list across Bad Boy, Exmark, Gravely, Hustler and Toro
  • 0.240 inch thickness stated

Cons

  • No warranty term stated on the listing
  • No weight stated on the listing
  • 5/8 inch center hole fits only mowers that take that size
Oregon Gator G3 22 Inch Mulching Blade

Oregon Gator G3 22 Inch Mulching Blade

Oregon9.4/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A single Gator G3 mulching blade for 22 inch decks, 21-11/16 inch long, 2.25 inch wide, 0.149 inch thick, 7/16 inch center hole, listed at 1.9 pounds.

Who it's for: owners of 22 inch Toro Recycler or Lawn-Boy mowers who mulch.

Who should skip it: anyone who needs a pair or a stated air lift figure.

The Oregon Gator G3 is a single mulching blade for 22 inch decks, 21-11/16 inch long, 2.25 inch wide and 0.149 inch thick, with a 7/16 inch center hole and a listed weight of 1.9 pounds. Its teeth finely cut and recut clippings into mulch, and the maker says that mulch feeds the yard while reducing bagging and cleanup. The spec table lists 21.63 inch length against 21-11/16 inch in the bullets.

Pros

  • Gator G3 teeth recut clippings into fine mulch
  • 0.149 inch thickness and 1.9 pound weight both stated
  • Fits listed Toro Recycler and Lawn-Boy models
  • Maker lists its history since 1947

Cons

  • Single blade in the pack
  • No warranty term stated on the listing
  • No air lift figure stated on the listing

Other machines to compare

Gator vs high lift mower blades side by side

Factor UDC 42 High Lift UDC Toro 22 Gator BCQNXX 60 High Lift Oregon Gator G3 22
Side High lift Gator High lift Gator
Deck fit 42 inch 22 inch 60 inch 22 inch
Blade length 21-1/4 inch 21-11/16 inch 20-1/2 inch 21-11/16 inch
Width 2-1/2 inch 2-1/2 inch 2-1/2 inch 2.25 inch
Air lift 1-7/64 inch 29/32 inch 29/32 inch Not stated
Cutting edge 6-57/64 inch 5-3/64 inch 7-1/16 inch Not stated
Mounting 6-point star 7/16 inch round 5/8 inch 7/16 inch
Pack 2-pack 2-pack 3-pack 1-pack
Acre Score 72 71 58 57

Figures are manufacturer stated for the examples, collected 4 November 2026.

Mulching teeth or lift wings

Gator teeth recut clippings as they pass under the deck. The Oregon example states that its teeth finely cut and recut grass clippings into mulch that feeds the yard while reducing bagging and cleanup, and the UDC gator example is a mulching blade for Toro Recycler decks with a 29/32 inch air lift stated.

High lift blades push air and clippings up from under the deck. The UDC high lift example states a 1-7/64 inch air lift, above the 29/32 inch stated on the UDC gator and BCQNXX examples, so lift alone does not separate every high lift blade from every gator blade.

Neither side wins on specs the other side leaves unstated: the Oregon gator example states no air lift figure, and the high lift examples state no recut claim as detailed as the Oregon claim.

Deck fit and mounting

Fit decides the purchase before blade style does. The gator examples fit 22 inch decks with a 7/16 inch round center hole, while the high lift examples fit 42 inch and 60 inch decks with a 6-point star and a 5/8 inch center hole.

Check the part number on the old blade against the fit list. The UDC high lift listing warns that other center hole patterns will not fit and that parts differ between configurations of the same model, while the BCQNXX and Oregon listings ask buyers to check the original part number and verify fit.

Length, edge and thickness

Blade length follows deck size here: 21-11/16 inch on the 22 inch gator examples, 21-1/4 inch on the 42 inch high lift example, and 20-1/2 inch on the 60 inch example. Cutting edge length runs the other way: 5-3/64 inch on the UDC gator example, 6-57/64 inch on the UDC high lift example, and 7-1/16 inch on the BCQNXX example, while the Oregon example states no cutting edge length. Thickness is stated on two examples only: 0.149 inch on the Oregon blade and 0.240 inch on the BCQNXX blade.

Pack size and upkeep

Pack size tracks deck size: a 2-pack and a single blade for 22 inch decks, a 2-pack for a 42 inch deck and a 3-pack for a 60 inch deck. Both UDC examples are pre-sharpened high-strength steel with an edge that can be resharpened, and both carry 1-year product support, while the Oregon and BCQNXX listings state no warranty term.

Acreage and terrain fit

UDC 42 High Lift

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough ground

UDC Toro 22 Gator

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatTrees and beds

BCQNXX 60 High Lift

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough ground

Oregon Gator G3 22

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatTrees and beds

How the scores work

The Acre Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. A factor the listing does not state scores zero, which is why the Oregon and BCQNXX examples score zero for warranty.

Product Acre Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
UDC 42 High Lift 9.6 29 21 21 3 3
UDC Toro 22 Gator 9.6 28 21 21 3 3
BCQNXX 60 High Lift 9.5 28 20 22 0 0
Oregon Gator G3 22 9.4 29 21 19 0 0

We show weighted point totals as scores from a 9.2 base up to a 9.8 peak, and a larger total can never read lower.

Many owners keep a spare set on hand: a gator set for mulching weeks and a high lift set for weeks when clippings need moving out. For deck care and blade changes, see the mower maintenance guides.

Mowing safety

Read the manual, keep children and pets out of the yard while you work, wear eye and hearing protection and sturdy footwear, and never exceed the slope rating of your machine. Refuel only with the engine off and cool. See CPSC lawn mower safety. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

Matching It to Your Property

  • Lawns with beds and trees suit the 22 inch gator examples, which match Recycler decks and their 7/16 inch round center hole.
  • Open ground mowed with a 42 inch riding mower suits the UDC high lift example and its 6-point star decks.
  • Wide 60 inch decks suit the BCQNXX high lift example and its 3-blade set.
  • A 2-pack for a single-blade 22 inch deck leaves a spare blade ready when an edge dulls.

FAQ: mowing large lots

Can gator blades bag clippings?

The Oregon listing says its gator teeth reduce bagging and cleanup by recutting clippings into mulch. Gator blades are built for mulching, and no bagging results are stated.

Do high lift blades mulch?

The UDC high lift listing carries mulching in its title, but its stated figures center on lift: a 1-7/64 inch air lift and a 6-57/64 inch cutting edge. No recut claim as detailed as the Oregon claim is stated.

How to tell which blade fits a mower?

Match the deck size, the center hole and the part number on the old blade. The gator examples fit 22 inch decks with a 7/16 inch round center hole, the UDC high lift example fits 42 inch decks with a 6-point star, and the BCQNXX example fits 60 inch decks with a 5/8 inch center hole.

Can a gator blade swap for a high lift blade?

Only when the deck size, center hole and part number match. The examples do not interchange: the gator examples use a 7/16 inch round center hole, while the UDC high lift example uses a 6-point star and the BCQNXX example uses a 5/8 inch center hole.

More mowing guides

More buying guides