Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Heat Pump vs Gas Pool Heater: Which One Should You Buy?

A heat pump vs gas pool heater guide that compares the stated heat pump models by pool gallons, BTU, COP, voltage and control, with no gas model featured.

Heat Pump vs Gas Pool Heater: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1JEMULICE Floating Pool FountainJEMULICE Floating Pool Fountain9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Swimming Pool Heater for Above Ground and Inground PoolSwimming Pool Heater for Above Ground and Inground PoolView on Amazon
  3. 3VARMINPOOL Swimming Pool Heater for Inground Pool 120000BTUVARMINPOOL Swimming Pool Heater for Inground Pool 120000BTUView on Amazon
  4. 4Vidapool Swimming Pool Heater Electric Pool Heat Pump 21000Vidapool Swimming Pool Heater Electric Pool Heat Pump 21000View on Amazon
  5. 5Varpoolfaye 120Varpoolfaye 120View on Amazon
  6. 6Varpoolfaye 30Varpoolfaye 30View on Amazon
  7. 7Varpoolfaye 65Varpoolfaye 65View on Amazon

A pool that sits cold through spring and fall shortens the swim season on a property, and heating choice decides how much of the year the water stays usable. In a heat pump vs gas pool heater comparison, the gear covered here is heat pump only: no gas pool heater model is featured, so the choice below rests on stated heat pump facts such as pool gallons, BTU, COP, voltage, heating and cooling modes, and control. Choose a heat pump when a stated model matches your pool gallons and power supply and you want heating and cooling from the same unit; a gas choice cannot be sized from the facts given here.

Other machines to compare

AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.

Heat pump vs gas pool heater: pick by pool size and power

Model Stated BTU Stated pool gallons Stated COP Voltage
VARMINPOOL pool heat pump 120000 BTU 33000 and 35000 12.3 220V
DOEL pool heat pump 119000 BTU 30000 15.8 220-240V
Vidapool pool heat pump 75000 BTU 21000 12 220V
AQUASTRONG pool heat pump 16000 BTU 5000 5.5 110V

The table ranks models by stated capacity. COP is the maker stated efficiency figure. Read pool gallons against your own pool before any other figure, because a model stated for a smaller pool is not sized for a larger pool in the facts given.

What a heat pump does here

Each model here is a heat pump with heating and cooling modes. Vidapool and DOEL describe air-source operation that captures heat from the air and moves it to pool water. AQUASTRONG states heating between 41 and 104 degrees and cooling within 41 and 83 degrees, with a thermostat stated to hold within 2 degrees. DOEL states a heating range of 47 to 104 degrees and a cooling range of 47 to 83 degrees, in ambient air from 5 to 109.4 degrees. Vidapool and VARMINPOOL state heating and cooling without giving the same range figures in the facts used here, so those ranges are not stated for them in this guide.

The gas side is mentioned only in maker energy claims: AQUASTRONG claims 40% more savings than natural gas alternatives and 70% less energy use than conventional electric heating, Vidapool claims up to 70% savings on energy costs compared to natural gas heaters, and DOEL states far less energy use than traditional gas pool heaters. Those are maker claims, reported as stated, and no gas model with stated BTU, gallons, COP or voltage is given to set beside them.

The gear, ranked by stated capacity

VARMINPOOL pool heat pump. The maker lists 120000 BTU, COP 12.3, a titanium heat exchanger, inverter control that adjusts output based on demand, WiFi control by app, and heating and cooling for inground pools and large above ground pools. The maker gives gallon figures of 33000 and 35000; check before ordering. The maker gives noise figures of 48 dB and 49 to 59 dB; check before ordering. Stated weight is 176 pounds, on 220V power, with an IPX4 rated cabinet.

DOEL pool heat pump. The maker lists 119000 BTU, a maximum COP of 15.8, a full DC inverter compressor and fan, WiFi app control with an LCD touch panel, schedules, and energy use monitoring. It is stated for above ground and inground pools up to 30000 gallons, for fresh water and salt water pools, with heating and cooling as above. Stated noise is as low as 59 dB at a distance of 1 meter. Stated features include R32 refrigerant, a 4-way valve auto-defrost system, an IPX4 rating, and safety features named as water-electric separation, electric leakage protection and anti-freeze protection.

Vidapool pool heat pump. The maker lists 75000 BTU, COP 12, heating and cooling, smart WiFi app control with schedules, and inverter control that switches to low-power operation once the set temperature is reached and adjusts output after that point. It is stated for pools up to 21000 gallons on 220V power. Stated noise is as low as 36 dB. ETL certification is stated. Connection options stated are 1.25 and 1.5 inch hose adapters, a 1.5 inch adapter conversion kit, and a 1.5 inch PVC pipe converter.

AQUASTRONG pool heat pump. The maker lists 16000 BTU, COP 5.5, heating and cooling as above, auto-defrost, and stated noise of 38 dB. It is stated for pools up to 5000 gallons on 110V power, with 1.25 inch hose adapters and 1.5 inch conversion kits. Stated weight is 72.0 pounds. A warranty term of 3 years is stated, with lifetime technical support also stated by the maker. The maker claims the unit extends swimming seasons by up to 6 months and that installation is completed in under 10 minutes; those are maker claims, not measured results here.

Match the model to pool gallons

Start with the gallons figure your pool holds and set it against the stated gallons for each model. The VARMINPOOL and DOEL models are stated for the largest pools here, Vidapool sits in the middle on stated gallons, and AQUASTRONG is stated for the smallest pools here. Do not move a gallons figure from a larger model to a smaller model, and do not size a gas heater from these figures, because no gas model gallons figure is stated.

VARMINPOOL states better temperature holding with proper circulation and pool cover use, and Vidapool recommends a pool cover in extreme temperatures. See our solar pool cover picks.

Check voltage and control

Voltage separates the smallest model from the rest. AQUASTRONG is stated at 110V, while Vidapool is stated at 220V, VARMINPOOL at 220V with a stated supply range of 220 to 240V at 60Hz, and DOEL at 220-240V. Match the stated voltage to the supply available at the pool pad and follow the maker manual for installation. Control also differs: VARMINPOOL, Vidapool and DOEL state WiFi app control, while AQUASTRONG states a panel with multi-mode smart control. Schedules are stated for VARMINPOOL, Vidapool and DOEL.

See our inground pool filter picks and pool pump timer picks when you plan the pad.

Read noise and outdoor build as stated

Stated noise figures are maker figures, not measurements taken here. Vidapool states as low as 36 dB and AQUASTRONG states 38 dB, while DOEL states as low as 59 dB at a distance of 1 meter and VARMINPOOL gives the figures noted above. Outdoor build points stated include a titanium heat exchanger for VARMINPOOL, an IPX4 rated cabinet for VARMINPOOL, and an IPX4 rating with anti-aging ABS casing for DOEL. Keep airflow clearance and water flow as the maker manual directs, as VARMINPOOL states.

Safety

Follow the maker manual for installation, power supply, airflow clearance and water flow, and keep children, pets and bystanders away from the work area during installation. Pool equipment here is described by stated figures only, with no wiring or bonding steps given in this guide. Where a maker states safety features, they are named in the gear section above, such as ETL certification for Vidapool and the named protections for DOEL. Drain and winter steps should follow the maker manual for the model you choose.

FAQ: mowing large lots

What size heat pump pool heater matches my pool?

Match your pool gallons to the stated gallons for each model: AQUASTRONG up to 5000 gallons, Vidapool up to 21000 gallons, DOEL up to 30000 gallons, and VARMINPOOL at 33000 and 35000 gallons as given by the maker. Check the VARMINPOOL figure before ordering.

Do these heat pumps heat and cool?

Yes, as stated by each maker. AQUASTRONG states heating between 41 and 104 degrees and cooling within 41 and 83 degrees, and DOEL states heating from 47 to 104 degrees and cooling from 47 to 83 degrees. Vidapool and VARMINPOOL state heating and cooling modes.

What voltage do these models use?

AQUASTRONG is stated at 110V. Vidapool and VARMINPOOL are stated at 220V, with VARMINPOOL also stating a supply range of 220 to 240V at 60Hz, and DOEL is stated at 220-240V. Follow the maker manual for the supply at your pool pad.

How loud are these heat pumps stated to be?

Stated figures are 36 dB as low as for Vidapool, 38 dB for AQUASTRONG, as low as 59 dB at a distance of 1 meter for DOEL, and 48 dB and 49 to 59 dB as given for VARMINPOOL. These are maker stated figures.

Is a gas pool heater model included here?

No gas pool heater model is featured here. The gas side appears only in maker energy claims, such as up to 70% savings compared to natural gas heaters as claimed for Vidapool and 40% more savings than natural gas alternatives as claimed for AQUASTRONG, with no stated gas BTU, gallons or voltage to compare.

More mowing guides

Browse the pool care category for more pool equipment guides.

More buying guides