Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Steel vs Plastic Garden Cart: Which One Should You Buy?

Steel and plastic garden carts compared on load capacity, bed size, tires, handles and upkeep, with examples from the listings we reviewed.

Steel vs Plastic Garden Cart: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR V1400 1400 lb Steel Garden CartVEVOR V1400 1400 lb Steel Garden Cart9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2VEVOR V900G 900 lb Steel Garden CartVEVOR V900G 900 lb Steel Garden Cart9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3FARM-TUFF Durable Plastic Deck Garden WagonFARM-TUFF Durable Plastic Deck Garden Wagon9.5/10View on Amazon

Verdict: Choose a steel garden cart if you haul heavy loads of soil, stone or tools and want a large bed that converts to a flatbed. Choose a plastic garden cart if your loads are lighter, you want a deck that will not rust, and you want a handle that folds under for storage.

The steel vs plastic garden cart question comes up when a wheelbarrow load turns into trip after trip across the property. Steel carts are built around a metal frame and mesh sides. Plastic carts are built around a plastic deck. This comparison covers what separates the two sides.

AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.

The three examples

VEVOR V1400 1400 lb Steel Garden Cart

VEVOR V1400 1400 lb Steel Garden Cart

VEVOR9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A steel garden cart with a 1,400 lb stated capacity and a 13.48 cu. ft. load bed, built as a fenced cart, a flatbed cart or a towable trailer.

Who it's for: owners who haul soil, stone and tools in heavy loads and want one cart that also tows.

Who should skip it: anyone who lifts the cart in and out of storage often, at 74.96 pounds listed.

The V1400 is the largest cart of the three examples: Q235 steel with three support beams, a powder-coated surface, a 1,400 lb stated capacity and a 13.48 cu. ft. load bed. It works as a fenced cart with mesh removable sides, as a flatbed cart, and as a towable trailer. One wrinkle: the part number reads Garden Cart 2 in 1, while the bullets describe a 3-in-1 design. The title also reads 2 in 1, so the listing disagrees with itself on the mode count; the modes listed here follow the bullets.

Pros

  • 1,400 lb stated capacity, the highest of the three
  • 13.48 cu. ft. load bed, the largest stated volume
  • Fenced, flatbed or towable trailer
  • 13-inch rubber tires, metal hubs

Cons

  • 74.96 pounds, the heaviest of the three
  • Part number says 2 in 1 while the bullets say 3-in-1
  • Warranty is not stated on the listing
  • No safety certification is stated
VEVOR V900G 900 lb Steel Garden Cart

VEVOR V900G 900 lb Steel Garden Cart

VEVOR9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A steel garden cart with a 900 lb stated capacity, a 4.52 cu. ft. load bed, 10-inch rubber tires and mesh removable sides that convert it to a flatbed.

Who it's for: owners who need a steel cart for heavy garden loads but want a smaller bed.

Who should skip it: anyone who needs the larger bed or a towable trailer mode, which this listing does not state.

The V900G is the smaller of the two steel examples: Q235 steel, a powder-coated surface, a 900 lb stated capacity and a 4.52 cu. ft. load bed. Mesh sides lift off to convert it to a flatbed cart. The T-shaped handle adjusts up to 180 degrees and has a rubber grip.

Pros

  • 900 lb stated load capacity
  • Mesh sides remove for flatbed use
  • Q235 steel, three beams, powder-coated
  • 10-inch rubber tires, metal hubs

Cons

  • 4.52 cu. ft. bed, smaller than the V1400
  • 39.68 pounds listed item weight
  • Warranty is not stated on the listing
  • No safety certification is stated
FARM-TUFF Durable Plastic Deck Garden Wagon

FARM-TUFF Durable Plastic Deck Garden Wagon

FARM-TUFF9.5/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A plastic deck garden wagon with a 300 lb stated capacity and a 37 in x 20 in bed with a 4 in cargo lip.

Who it's for: owners hauling plants, soil and tools in lighter loads who want a cart that will not rust and stores small.

Who should skip it: anyone hauling stone or heavy loads near the 300 lb limit.

The FARM-TUFF wagon is the only plastic example: a heavy-duty polyethylene deck the listing calls BPA-free, with a 300 lb stated capacity and a bed the bullets list as 37 in x 20 in with a 4 in cargo lip. It rides on four 4 in x 10 in tires and steers with a powder-coated D-handle that folds under for compact storage. Two details disagree: the title gives the deck as 38 in x 20 in, and the same bullet calls the tires both solid and pneumatic. We follow the bullets.

Pros

  • 25.75 pounds, the lightest of the three
  • Deck resists cracks, dents and weather damage
  • D-handle folds under
  • Four tires, anti-tip balance

Cons

  • 300 lb stated capacity, the lowest of the three
  • Bed size listed two ways, 38 in and 37 in
  • Tires called both solid and pneumatic
  • Warranty is not stated on the listing

Other machines to compare

Steel vs plastic garden cart side by side

Factor VEVOR V1400 Steel Cart VEVOR V900G Steel Cart FARM-TUFF Poly Cart
Material Q235 steel, powder-coated Q235 steel, powder-coated Polyethylene deck, BPA-free
Load capacity (stated) 1,400 lbs 900 lbs 300 lbs
Load bed (stated) 13.48 cu. ft. 4.52 cu. ft. 37 in x 20 in; volume not stated
Tires (stated) 13-inch rubber, metal hubs 10-inch rubber, metal hubs Four 4 in x 10 in, solid pneumatic
Handle 180 degree rotating, rubber grip 180 degree rotating, rubber grip D-handle, folds under
Modes Fenced cart, flatbed, towable trailer Fenced cart, flatbed Deck cart, 4 in lip
Item weight (stated) 74.96 pounds 39.68 pounds 25.75 pounds
Best at Heavy loads Heavy loads, smaller bed Light loads, easy storage

Figures are manufacturer stated for the examples, collected 10 November 2026.

Load capacity: where steel pulls ahead

Load capacity is the clearest split between the two sides. The VEVOR V1400 example lists 1,400 lbs, and the VEVOR V900G example lists 900 lbs. The FARM-TUFF example lists 300 lbs. For heavy loads of soil, stone or tools, the steel examples list more capacity. For plants and hand tools, the plastic example lists enough.

Material: steel frame or plastic deck

Both steel examples use Q235 steel with three support beams on the base and a powder-coated surface that the listing says resists corrosion. Mesh sides come off, so either steel cart converts to a flatbed. The plastic example uses a polyethylene deck that the listing says resists cracks, dents and weather damage, and the deck is BPA-free. Steel gives a rigid frame for heavy loads. Plastic gives a deck with no coating to maintain.

Bed size and shape

Bed volume is stated for the steel side only. The V1400 example lists a 13.48 cu. ft. load bed, and the V900G example lists a 4.52 cu. ft. load bed. The plastic example states no bed volume: the bullets list a 37 in x 20 in bed with a 4 in cargo lip, while the title lists 38 in x 20 in. The listing leaves the exact bed size unclear, so compare the steel beds by volume and the plastic bed by its stated inches.

Tires and ground

Both steel examples list rubber tires. The steel pair names grass, mud, rocks and snow; the plastic wagon names cement, soil and grass. The V1400 example lists 13-inch tires, the V900G example lists 10-inch tires, and the FARM-TUFF example lists four 4 in x 10 in tires. The plastic listing calls its tires both solid and pneumatic, so the tire type is unclear.

Handles and steering

Both steel examples use a handle that rotates 180 degrees. The V900G handle is T-shaped. The plastic example steers with a powder-coated D-handle and auto-type steering, and the handle folds under for compact storage. The V1400 example also tows: its listing says it works as a towable trailer as well as a fenced cart and a flatbed cart.

Storage and upkeep

The plastic deck needs no coating, and its folding D-handle is the clearest storage win: the handle folds under the deck. Neither steel listing states a folding handle.

Acreage and terrain fit

VEVOR V1400 Steel Cart

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough groundTrees and beds

VEVOR V900G Steel Cart

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough groundTrees and beds

FARM-TUFF Poly Cart

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatTrees and beds

Matching It to Your Property

  • Flat lawns and beds: all three listings name grass as ground they handle.
  • Rough ground: the steel examples list 10-inch and 13-inch rubber tires, metal hubs.
  • Tight storage: the plastic example lists a D-handle that folds under for compact storage.
  • Bulky loads: the steel examples list mesh sides that remove to make a flatbed, and the V1400 also lists a towable trailer mode.

The Acre Score explained

The Acre Score weighs five factors: performance (capacity and bed), build quality (frame, tires and handle), value (what comes in the box), safety (certifications the listing states) and warranty (years and coverage). A factor the listing does not state scores zero.

Product Acre Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
VEVOR V1400 Steel Cart 9.6 30 21 21 n/a 0
VEVOR V900G Steel Cart 9.6 29 21 20 n/a 0
FARM-TUFF Poly Cart 9.5 26 19 20 n/a 0

The bottom of our scale is 9.2 and the top is 9.8; weighted totals map onto it in a straight line, keeping their order. Manual gear with no listed safety feature is not scored on safety, and the other 90 points decide its total.

If you haul heavy loads most weekends, the steel examples list the capacity for it. If you haul lighter garden loads and want a cart that stores small, the plastic example lists the deck and the folding handle for it. See our best garden cart picks.

Towing and attachment safety

Stay within the towing capacity and hitch weight your mower manual lists, and add weight slowly. Loaded carts and spreaders push a mower downhill, so take slopes straight up and down at low speed. Keep riders off carts and keep bystanders clear while you tow. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ: mowing large lots

Can a plastic garden cart haul soil and stone?

The FARM-TUFF example lists a 300 lb capacity. The steel examples list 900 lbs and 1,400 lbs for heavier loads.

Do steel garden carts rust?

The steel examples list a powder-coated surface that the maker says resists corrosion. The plastic deck needs no coating.

Can you tow a garden cart behind a mower?

The V1400 example lists a towable trailer mode, so it is the only one of the three examples that states towing. The other two listings describe pulling by hand.

What bed size do I need in a garden cart?

The V1400 example lists 13.48 cu. ft., the V900G example lists 4.52 cu. ft., and the plastic example lists a 37 in x 20 in bed with a 4 in cargo lip in its bullets, while its title lists 38 in.

More mowing guides

Use the Mower Matcher to narrow down choices by acreage, terrain, budget, and power type.

More buying guides