Reel Mower vs Rotary: Which One Should You Buy?
Two manual reel mowers compared on cutting width, cutting height, weight and catcher, with the rotary side described only as the powered alternative.
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Fiskars StaySharp Max 18 in Push Reel Mower9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
American Lawn Mower 2002-20 20-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower with9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
American Lawn Mower 1804-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower with9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Great States 415-16 16-Inch Reel Lawn Mower with T-StyleView on Amazon - 5
GC91820 18-Inch/20-Inch Reel Mower Grass CatcherView on Amazon - 6
Rotary Item 12179View on Amazon
Verdict: Choose a reel mower if the lawn is regularly maintained and clear of debris, and quiet manual cutting suits the property. A rotary mower is the powered alternative for buyers who want powered cutting rather than pushing effort, but no rotary example is featured here, so this article compares the two reel examples on their stated specs.
A small lawn, mowed often, is where the reel mower vs rotary question matters most. A reel mower cuts with rotating blades in a scissor-like cut and runs on pushing effort alone, while a rotary mower is the powered alternative. Both featured mowers here are reel mowers from the same maker, so this article compares the two reel examples on cutting width, cutting height, weight and catcher, and leaves the rotary side to the powered alternative it represents.
AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.
American Lawn Mower 2002-20 20-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower with Grass Catcher
The wider reel pick for covering more lawn per pass, with a 20-inch cut and a grass catcher.
Who it's for: a buyer with a regularly maintained lawn who wants the wider cut and a catcher that can be left off.
Who should skip it: anyone who mows below 2 in, since the stated range starts there.
Read the full review
The listing states a 20-inch 5-blade reel mower with a grass catcher, manual push power and a weight of 28.6 lb. Two figures disagree inside the listing: the heading states a 1- to 3-inch cutting height while the bullets and spec table state 2 to 3 in, and the spec table lists 1 position against an adjustable height claim. The bullets advise a higher setting for longer or thicker grass, lowered gradually in later passes to help prevent binding and missed grass. No warranty term is stated.
Pros
- 20-inch cutting width covers more lawn per pass
- 5-blade reel for a scissor-like cut
- Grass catcher included, and the mower can run without it
- No gas, oil, batteries, charging or cords
Cons
- Heading states 1- to 3-inch heights while the bullets and spec table state 2 to 3 in
- Spec table lists 1 position against an adjustable height claim
- No warranty term is stated
- Heavier at 28.6 lb than the 18-inch example
American Lawn Mower 1804-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Reel Mower with Grass Catcher
The height-range reel pick for low cutting, with a 1/2 to 2-3/4 inch range across 7 positions.
Who it's for: a buyer with a small, regularly maintained lawn who wants low cutting and many height settings.
Who should skip it: anyone with tall, thick or debris-heavy grass, or a lawn too large for a compact catcher.
Read the full review
The listing states an 18-inch 5-blade reel mower with a grass catcher, manual push power, a weight of 27.3 lb and a cutting height from 1/2 to 2-3/4 in across 7 positions. It operates more quietly than most powered mowers but requires physical pushing effort, and it performs best on dry, regularly maintained grass. Tall or thick areas may require slower, overlapping passes, and sticks, pinecones and other hard debris must be removed before mowing to prevent the reel from jamming. No warranty term is stated.
Pros
- 18-inch cutting width with a 1/2 to 2-3/4 in height range
- 7 height positions stated
- 5-blade reel for a scissor-like cut
- Grass catcher included; no gas, oil, batteries, charging or cords
Cons
- Catcher capacity is compact and needs frequent emptying
- Tall or thick grass needs slower, overlapping passes
- Debris such as sticks and pinecones must be cleared to prevent jamming
- No warranty term is stated
Other machines to compare
Great States 415-16 16-Inch Reel Lawn Mower with T-StyleCheck price on Amazon
GC91820 18-Inch/20-Inch Reel Mower Grass CatcherCheck price on Amazon
Rotary Item 12179Check price on Amazon
Reel mower vs rotary side by side
| Factor | American 2002-20 Reel | American 1804-18 Reel | Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cutting width | 20 in | 18 in | Wider cut on the 2002-20 |
| Cutting height | 2 to 3 in | 1/2 to 2-3/4 in | Wider height range on the 1804-18 |
| Blades | 5 | 5 | Same blade count |
| Weight | 28.6 lb | 27.3 lb | Lighter: the 1804-18 |
| Power | Manual | Manual | Same manual power |
| Catcher | Included | Included | Both include a catcher |
| Warranty | Not stated | Not stated | Neither states a warranty |
Figures are manufacturer stated for the two example models, collected 25 October 2026.
Cutting width and height
Width is the clearest difference between the two examples. The 2002-20 cuts 20 in wide, while the 1804-18 cuts 18 in wide, so the wider model covers more lawn with each pass. Height runs the other way: the 1804-18 adjusts from 1/2 to 2-3/4 in across 7 positions, while the 2002-20 adjusts from 2 to 3 in. A buyer who mows low should favor the 1804-18 range, while a buyer who mows at 2 to 3 in and wants width should favor the 2002-20.
Power and effort
Both mowers are manual and engine-free: no gas, oil, batteries, charging or electrical cords, per both listings. The 1804-18 listing states it operates more quietly than most powered mowers, but requires physical pushing effort. Tall or thick grass may require slower, overlapping passes on the 1804-18, and the 2002-20 listing advises lowering the height gradually in later passes to help prevent binding and missed grass. Neither listing states a powered option, so pushing effort is part of the deal on both.
Catcher and debris
Both mowers include a grass catcher. The 1804-18 listing warns that its compact catcher capacity may be impractical for thick grass or large lawns, that it must be emptied frequently, and that some clippings may remain on the lawn. The 2002-20 listing also advises emptying frequently, since accumulated clippings can interfere with the reel, but adds that the mower may run without the catcher when collection is not required. The 1804-18 listing also warns to remove sticks, pinecones and other hard debris before mowing to prevent the reel from jamming.
What the listings leave unclear
Two figures disagree inside the 2002-20 listing: its heading states a 1- to 3-inch cutting height, while its bullets and spec table state 2 to 3 in, and its spec table lists 1 position against an adjustable height claim. The 1804-18 listing is consistent on height, stating 1/2 to 2-3/4 in in both bullets and spec table. Neither listing states a warranty term, and neither states a rotary figure, since no rotary mower is featured here. In each case the bullets are the safer figures to trust over a heading or a single spec field.
The two examples
Acreage and terrain fit
American 2002-20 Reel
American 1804-18 Reel
Matching It to Your Property
- Match cutting width to the lawn: 20 in covers more lawn per pass than 18 in.
- Match height range to the grass: 1/2 to 2-3/4 in against 2 to 3 in.
- Match power to the property: manual push power with no fuel, battery or cord on either model.
- Match the catcher to the job: both include one, and the 2002-20 can also run without it.
- Clear sticks, pinecones and hard debris before mowing to prevent the reel from jamming.
Walk the area first and clear stones, sticks, wire and toys. Wear eye and hearing protection, long pants and sturdy closed footwear, mow across slopes with a walk-behind (not up and down), and never pull a running mower toward you. Keep kids and pets well away. Refuel only with the engine off and cool. See CPSC lawn mower safety. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
The Acre Score explained
The Acre Score weighs five factors: performance (cutting width, height range and cut quality), build quality (materials and catcher), value (what comes in the box), safety (features the listing states) and warranty (terms the listing states). A factor the listing does not state scores zero, which is why both examples score zero for safety and warranty.
| Product | Acre Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| American 2002-20 Reel | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| American 1804-18 Reel | 9.6 | 28 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each product’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score. Safety counts only for powered gear or where the listing states safety features; where it does not apply, the score is taken over the remaining 90 points.
A reel mower suits a small, regularly maintained lawn where quiet manual cutting is enough. The wider model covers more ground per pass, while the narrower model offers the wider height range and more height positions.
FAQ: mowing large lots
Are reel mowers better than rotary mowers?
The listings here cover only reel mowers, so this article cannot score the rotary side. A reel mower cuts quietly without fuel on regularly maintained grass, while a rotary mower is the powered alternative.
Why choose a reel mower?
No gas, oil, batteries, charging or cords, and quiet operation with no engine exhaust, per the listings. The trade is pushing effort and slower passes on tall or thick grass.
What size reel mower should I buy?
The examples here cut 18 in and 20 in wide, with heights of 1/2 to 2-3/4 in and 2 to 3 in. Match width to the lawn and height range to the grass.
How do you set the cutting height?
Start at a higher setting and reduce gradually on later passes, per the listings. The 1804-18 offers 7 positions across its range, while the 2002-20 lists 1 position.
Does a reel mower need a grass catcher?
Both examples include a catcher, and the 2002-20 listing says it may also run without one. The 1804-18 listing warns its compact catcher needs frequent emptying.
More mowing guides
- Best Manual Reel Mower (2026): 5 Top Picks Compared
- Best Reel Mower (2026): 5 Picks Compared
- Best Reel Mower for Bermuda Grass (2026): 5 Top Picks Compared
- Best Walk Behind Push Mower: 5 Picks Compared (2026)
Use the walk-behind and robotic mowers guide for more walk-behind options.
