Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Aluminum vs Steel Mower Trailer: Which One Should You Buy?

2 steel dump carts compared on capacity, build and upkeep, with a straight answer on the aluminum vs steel mower trailer question and what the listings leave unclear.

Aluminum vs Steel Mower Trailer: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1MOVECOM 750 lb Steel Dump CartMOVECOM 750 lb Steel Dump Cart9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2EliteEdge 750 lb Steel Dump CartEliteEdge 750 lb Steel Dump Cart9.6/10View on Amazon

Verdict: Choose steel if the documented capacity and build match the work: both listings here are steel carts rated 750 lb with 17 cu ft beds. Aluminum has no listing in this article, so its side cannot be scored from these listings; pick aluminum only from a listing that states the same capacity, weight and coating figures.

A load of branches, a pile of gravel, a season of firewood: the trailer behind the mower does the hauling, and the metal it is made from affects how it holds up. The aluminum vs steel mower trailer question comes down to what the listings actually state, so this article starts from the listings themselves.

The listings supplied here are 2 steel dump carts with the same stated capacity and the same stated weight, and no aluminum cart. That shapes the whole comparison: the steel side has figures to check, and the aluminum side has questions to ask before buying.

AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.

The examples

MOVECOM 750 lb Steel Dump Cart

MOVECOM 750 lb Steel Dump Cart

MOVECOM9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A steel dump cart rated 750 lb with a 17 cu ft bed, heavy-gauge steel sidewalls, double-braced reinforcements and 16x4-inch pneumatic tires, with a foot-pedal dump release.

The MOVECOM cart is a steel dump cart rated 750 lb with a 17 cu ft bed, built from heavy-gauge steel sidewalls with double-braced reinforcements. It unloads with a removable tailgate or a foot-pedal dump release, and it rolls on 16x4-inch pneumatic tires over rough ground.

Pros

  • 750 lb capacity, 17 cu ft bed stated
  • Heavy-gauge steel with double-braced reinforcements
  • Foot-pedal dump release plus removable tailgate
  • 16x4-inch pneumatic tires for rough ground

Cons

  • No warranty stated
  • Stated dimensions, 45.67 by 18.11 by 9.84 in, differ sharply from the other listing
  • Hitch pin size not stated
  • Coating type not stated, only rust-resistant coating claimed
EliteEdge 750 lb Steel Dump Cart

EliteEdge 750 lb Steel Dump Cart

EliteEdge9.6/10 Acre Score
i
The Acre Score (out of 100, shown as /10) weighs rated performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. How we score

A steel dump cart rated 750 lb with a 17 cu ft bed, heavy-gauge steel with double-braced reinforcements and 16x4-inch pneumatic tires, with a removable side and foot-pedal dump release.

The EliteEdge cart states the same headline figures as the MOVECOM cart: 750 lb capacity, a 17 cu ft bed and 85.98 lb weight, with heavy-gauge steel, double-braced reinforcements and 16x4-inch pneumatic tires. It unloads the same way, with a removable tailgate or a foot-pedal release, and hitches to riding mowers, utility vehicles and compact tractors with a standard hitch.

Pros

  • 750 lb capacity, 17 cu ft bed stated
  • Heavy-gauge steel with double-braced reinforcements
  • Foot-pedal dump release plus removable tailgate
  • 16x4-inch pneumatic tires for rough ground

Cons

  • No warranty stated
  • Stated dimensions, 79.0 by 30.0 by 30.0 in, differ sharply from the other listing, so bed size is unclear
  • Hitch pin size not stated
  • Coating type not stated, only rust-resistant finish claimed

Other machines to compare

Aluminum vs steel mower trailer side by side

Factor Steel cart (MOVECOM) Steel cart (EliteEdge) Aluminum side
Capacity (stated) 750 lb, 17 cu ft 750 lb, 17 cu ft No listing supplied
Dimensions (stated) 45.67 by 18.11 by 9.84 in 79.0 by 30.0 by 30.0 in No listing supplied
Cart weight (stated) 85.98 lb 85.98 lb No listing supplied
Tires 16×4-inch pneumatic 16×4-inch pneumatic No listing supplied
Dump Removable tailgate, foot-pedal release Removable tailgate, foot-pedal release No listing supplied
Hitch Standard hitch Standard hitch No listing supplied
Coating Rust-resistant coating Rust-resistant finish No listing supplied
Warranty Not stated Not stated No listing supplied

Figures are manufacturer stated for the example models, collected 11 November 2026.

Capacity and bed size

Both carts state the same capacity: 750 lb and 17 cu ft. That is the headline figure for hauling firewood, gravel and yard debris, and it is the same on each listing.

The bed size is where the listings part ways. The MOVECOM listing states dimensions of 45.67 by 18.11 by 9.84 in, while the EliteEdge listing states 79.0 by 30.0 by 30.0 in. The two listings state very different dimensions for carts with the same stated capacity and weight, so neither listing settles the bed size on its own: measure the bed before ordering, and treat the 17 cu ft figure as the capacity to compare.

Build: steel on both sides

Both carts are heavy-gauge steel with double-braced reinforcements, and both claim resistance to warping under stress. The MOVECOM listing calls out heavy-gauge steel sidewalls; the EliteEdge listing calls out an all-steel build. Reinforced side panels on each cart are meant to prevent spillage while hauling.

Both listings also state a rust-resistant coating or finish. Neither names the coating type, so the claim is the same on each side: a coating is listed, and its makeup is not. With no aluminum listing in the set, the comparison cannot say how an aluminum bed would hold up beside these steel ones; that side of the question stays open.

Dumping and hitching

Both carts unload the same way: a removable tailgate, or a foot-pedal release that dumps the bed hands-free. The foot pedal matters on a long day of mulch or compost runs, when climbing off the mower to work the tailgate by hand gets old.

Both carts hitch with a standard hitch to riding mowers, utility vehicles and compact tractors. Neither listing states a hitch pin size, so check the pin against the tow vehicle’s hitch before ordering.

Tires and rough ground

Both carts roll on 16×4-inch pneumatic tires, which the listings say absorb shocks and vibration on uneven ground. That is the tire figure for gravel drives, rutted paths and open fields alike. Neither listing states a tire pressure or a load limit for the tires themselves, so the 750 lb figure is the cart figure, not a tire figure.

Acreage and terrain fit

MOVECOM Dump Cart

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough ground

EliteEdge Dump Cart

Acreage fitUnder 11-22-55-1010+
Terrain fitFlatRough ground

Matching It to Your Property

  • Both carts state 16×4-inch pneumatic tires for rough ground, so ruts, gravel drives and open fields are part of the job they claim.
  • Both carts state a standard hitch for riding mowers, utility vehicles and compact tractors, so check the tow vehicle has that hitch.
  • Both carts weigh 85.98 lb stated, so plan a parking spot and storage space for a cart that size.
  • The carts state different dimensions, so measure the storage bay against the stated figures before ordering.

The Acre Score explained

The Acre Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. Here, performance covers stated capacity and hauling build, value covers what comes in the box, and safety covers certifications or operator controls the listing states. A factor the listing does not state gets no points, which is why the examples get no points for warranty and none for safety.

Product Acre Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
MOVECOM Dump Cart 9.6 28 21 20 n/a 0
EliteEdge Dump Cart 9.6 28 20 20 n/a 0

Acre Scores are spread from 9.2 up to 9.8, and each weighted total takes its place on that spread proportionally, so the mower with more points is always shown above the one with fewer. Manual gear with no listed safety feature is not scored on safety, and the other 90 points decide its total.

For more hauling gear, see our tow-behind attachments, and for the hitch hardware, see lawn mower trailer hitch for garden tractor.

Towing and attachment safety

Stay within the towing capacity and hitch weight your mower manual lists, and add weight slowly. Loaded carts and spreaders push a mower downhill, so take slopes straight up and down at low speed. Keep riders off carts and keep bystanders clear while you tow. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ: mowing large lots

Is a steel mower trailer heavier than an aluminum one?

The listings here state 85.98 lb for each steel cart and give no aluminum figure, so this article cannot compare the weights. Check the stated weight on any aluminum listing before comparing, and compare the same measure: cart weight against cart weight.

What capacity should a mower trailer have?

The listings here state 750 lb and 17 cu ft. Match the stated capacity to the loads the property produces: firewood, gravel and yard debris are the loads these listings name. Check the tow vehicle’s towing limit in its manual before loading the cart.

Do steel trailers rust?

Both listings state a rust-resistant coating or finish, without naming the coating type. A coating is a claim on the listing, not a promise the steel cannot rust, so store the cart under cover and keep the coating in good shape.

Can a riding mower tow a dump cart?

Both listings state a standard hitch and name riding mowers, utility vehicles and compact tractors as tow vehicles. Check the mower’s manual for its towing limit before loading the cart.

More mowing guides

More buying guides