Aluminum vs Steel Snow Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?
Aluminum and steel snow shovels compared on blade size, weight, handles and upkeep, with two examples from each side and a verdict.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Hathoro Snow Shovel with Wide 24-inch Steel Blade and 42-inch D-Grip Wood Handle9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
KOLEIYA Aluminum Snow Shovel, 45-Inch, Large Capacity Scoop, Fiberglass D-Handle9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Hathoro Snow Shovel with 18-inch Steel Blade, D-Grip and 37-inch Wood Handle9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Showvigor Upgraded Aluminum Alloy Snow Shovel, Lightweight and Portable9.4/10View on Amazon
Verdict: Choose the KOLEIYA aluminum example if you want the lowest stated weight here, or the Showvigor aluminum example if you want a shovel that rides in a car trunk. Choose steel if you want the widest stated blade for pushing: the Hathoro 24-inch example carries it.
A driveway full of snow and a walk to clear before the day starts is the job, and the shovel by the door decides how much effort it takes. The aluminum vs steel snow shovel choice comes down to blade material, weight and handle, and this comparison puts two examples from each side next to each other.
AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.
The four examples

Hathoro Snow Shovel with Wide 24-inch Steel Blade and 42-inch D-Grip Wood Handle
A snow pusher with a 24-inch wide, 10-inch high steel blade and a 42-inch wood handle with a D-grip, listed at 5.0 pounds with a 52-inch overall length.
Who it's for: someone clearing a wide driveway who wants the widest stated blade here.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants the lowest stated weight, since the KOLEIYA example lists 3.7 pounds.
Hathoro lists this snow pusher with a 24-inch wide and 10-inch high steel blade, a 42-inch wood handle with a D-grip, and a 52-inch overall length, at 5.0 pounds. The listing states use for driveways, sidewalks and pathways, for light powder and packed snow. The spec table gives dimensions of 52.0 by 24.0 by 52.0 inches, so 52 inches appears twice unexplained.
Pros
- 24-inch wide steel blade for pushing snow
- 42-inch wood handle with a D-grip
- Listed for light powder and packed snow
- 52-inch overall length for leverage and reach
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No blade thickness is stated
- 5.0 pounds, the same as the smaller Hathoro example

KOLEIYA Aluminum Snow Shovel, 45-Inch, Large Capacity Scoop, Fiberglass D-Handle
A 45-inch aluminum snow shovel with a 19 by 14 inch scoop and a fiberglass D-handle, listed at 3.7 pounds in the bullets.
Who it's for: someone who wants the lowest stated weight here and a large scoop.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants a stated blade thickness or a warranty term, since the listing states neither.
KOLEIYA lists this snow shovel with a 45-inch fiberglass handle, a non-slip D-grip and a 19 by 14 inch aluminum alloy scoop, at 3.7 pounds in the bullets. The listing describes the blade as wear resistant for thick ice and compacted snow, with grain, mulch, manure, gravel, coal and leaves listed as other uses. The spec table says 3.5 pounds, so this article uses the bullets figure.
Pros
- 19 by 14 inch scoop moves more snow per pass
- 3.7 pounds as listed in the bullets, the lowest stated weight here
- 45-inch fiberglass handle with a non-slip D-grip
- Arrives assembled in one piece, ready to use
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No blade thickness is stated
- No scoop depth is stated

Hathoro Snow Shovel with 18-inch Steel Blade, D-Grip and 37-inch Wood Handle
A snow pusher with an 18-inch steel blade and a 37-inch wood handle with a D-grip, listed at 5.0 pounds.
Who it's for: someone who wants a steel pusher with a shorter handle.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants the widest stated blade, since the 24-inch Hathoro example is wider.
Hathoro lists this snow pusher with an 18-inch wide steel blade, a 37-inch wood handle with a D-grip, and a weight of 5.0 pounds. The listing states use for driveways, sidewalks and pathways, for light powder and packed snow. The spec table gives dimensions of 18.0 by 18.0 by 49.0 inches, while the bullets state only the 37-inch handle.
Pros
- 18-inch steel blade for pushing snow
- 37-inch wood handle with a D-grip
- Listed for light powder and packed snow
- Steel blade and wood handle for multiple winter seasons
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No blade thickness is stated
- 5.0 pounds, the same as the wider 24-inch Hathoro example
- Overall length is not stated in the bullets; the spec table lists 49.0 inches

Showvigor Upgraded Aluminum Alloy Snow Shovel, Lightweight and Portable
A lightweight aluminum alloy snow shovel for car and driveway use, described as portable and compact for a car trunk.
Who it's for: someone who wants a spare shovel that rides in a car trunk for unexpected snowfall.
Who should skip it: anyone who needs a stated blade size, handle length or weight.
Showvigor lists this snow shovel as an upgraded aluminum alloy build for car and driveway use. The listing states a reinforced aluminum alloy blade and handle, rust and corrosion resistance, and use for driveways, walkways and car rooftops, with a design that fits in a car trunk. The spec table lists 1.0 pound and dimensions of 1.0 by 1.0 by 1.0 inches, which do not describe a shovel, so weight, blade size and handle length are treated as not stated.
Pros
- Aluminum alloy build stated to resist rust and corrosion
- Designed to fit in a car trunk for unexpected snowfall
- Reinforced aluminum alloy blade and handle
- Listed for driveways, walkways and car rooftops
Cons
- No weight is stated; the spec table lists 1.0 pound with 1.0-inch dimensions
- No blade size is stated
- No handle length is stated
- No warranty term is stated
Other machines to compare
Ashman Aluminium 48 inch Snow Shovel with Large Head andCheck price on Amazon
Aluminum Snow ShovelCheck price on Amazon
Snow Shovel for DrivewayCheck price on Amazon
True Temper 1641200 Aluminum Snow Shovel with ErgonomicCheck price on Amazon
True Temper 1681400 Aluminum Scoop Shovel with HardwoodCheck price on Amazon
SubZero 17222 Collapsible Snow ShovelCheck price on Amazon
Aluminum vs steel snow shovel side by side
| Factor | Steel (Hathoro 24 in) | Aluminum (KOLEIYA 45 in) | Steel (Hathoro 18 in) | Aluminum (Showvigor) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blade material | Steel | Aluminum alloy | Steel | Aluminum alloy |
| Blade size (stated) | 24 in wide, 10 in high | 19 by 14 in scoop | 18 in wide, 18 in high | Not stated |
| Handle | 42 in wood, D-grip, 52 in overall | 45 in fiberglass, D-grip | 37 in wood, D-grip | Aluminum alloy, length not stated |
| Weight (stated) | 5.0 lb | 3.7 lb in bullets; 3.5 lb in spec table | 5.0 lb | Not stated |
| Best at | Driveways, sidewalks, pathways | Driveway, sidewalk, deck; grain, mulch, gravel | Driveways, sidewalks, pathways | Driveway, walkway, car rooftop |
Figures are manufacturer stated for the four example models, collected 12 November 2026.
Blade material: aluminum or steel
Both aluminum examples use an aluminum alloy blade. The KOLEIYA listing describes its blade as wear resistant for thick ice and compacted snow, while the Showvigor listing states its aluminum alloy resists rust and corrosion season after season. Both steel examples use a steel blade with a wood handle, described as durable steel for pushing heavy snow from driveways, sidewalks and pathways, and the listings claim the steel and wood combination gives long-lasting durability for multiple winter seasons.
Weight and handling
Weight is stated for three of the four examples. The KOLEIYA example lists 3.7 pounds in its bullets against 3.5 pounds in its spec table; the bullets figure is used here. Both Hathoro examples list 5.0 pounds each. The Showvigor example states no weight: its spec table lists 1.0 pound with 1.0 by 1.0 by 1.0 inch dimensions, which do not describe a shovel.
The KOLEIYA has a 45-inch fiberglass handle with a non-slip D-grip, and the listing says the handle promotes a more natural shoveling posture. The Hathoro examples have wood handles with D-grips, 37 inches on the 18-inch example and 42 inches on the 24-inch example. The Showvigor example states no handle length, only a reinforced aluminum alloy blade and handle.
Blade size and what each one clears
The KOLEIYA example carries a 19 by 14 inch scoop, and the listing says the oversized blade moves more snow with each pass across driveways, sidewalks and decks. The Hathoro 24-inch example has the widest stated blade here at 24 inches wide and 10 inches high, while the Hathoro 18-inch example has an 18-inch wide steel blade, and the Showvigor example states no blade size. All four examples are listed for driveways and walkways. The KOLEIYA example also lists grain, mulch, manure, gravel, coal and leaves, and the Showvigor example adds car rooftops and a car trunk fit.
Upkeep
The listings state little about upkeep. The KOLEIYA example arrives assembled in one piece, and the other three listings state no assembly or upkeep details.
Acreage and terrain fit
Hathoro 24 in Shovel
KOLEIYA 45 in Shovel
Hathoro 18 in Shovel
Showvigor Alloy Shovel
Matching It to Your Property
- The KOLEIYA shovel has a 45-inch fiberglass handle and a 19 by 14 inch scoop.
- The Showvigor shovel is built to ride in a car trunk for unexpected snowfall.
- The Hathoro 24-inch shovel has the widest stated blade here for pushing snow.
- The Hathoro 18-inch shovel has a 37-inch wood handle for a shorter reach.
The Acre Score explained
The Acre Score weighs five factors: performance (blade size, what it can clear, handling), build quality (blade and handle materials), value (what comes in the box, how many jobs it covers), safety (controls the listing states) and warranty. A factor the listing does not state scores zero, which is why all four examples score zero for safety and warranty.
| Product | Acre Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hathoro 24 in Shovel | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| KOLEIYA 45 in Shovel | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| Hathoro 18 in Shovel | 9.6 | 28 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| Showvigor Alloy Shovel | 9.4 | 24 | 19 | 18 | n/a | 0 |
The bottom of our scale is 9.2 and the top is 9.8; weighted totals map onto it in a straight line, keeping their order. If an item uses no power and names no safety feature, safety is dropped and the scale becomes 90 points.
If you push snow across a wide driveway, see our snow pusher vs shovel comparison.
Read the manual, keep children and pets out of the yard while you work, wear eye and hearing protection and sturdy footwear, and never exceed the slope rating of your machine. Refuel only with the engine off and cool. See CPSC lawn mower safety. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ: mowing large lots
Is an aluminum snow shovel lighter than a steel snow shovel?
For the examples with stated weights, yes. The KOLEIYA aluminum example lists 3.7 pounds in its bullets, while both Hathoro steel examples list 5.0 pounds each. The Showvigor example states no weight.
What blade sizes do these snow shovels have?
The KOLEIYA example has a 19 by 14 inch scoop, the Hathoro 24-inch example a 24-inch wide and 10-inch high steel blade, and the Hathoro 18-inch example an 18-inch wide steel blade.
What handle lengths do these snow shovels have?
The KOLEIYA example has a 45-inch fiberglass handle, the Hathoro 18-inch example a 37-inch wood handle, and the Hathoro 24-inch example a 42-inch wood handle with a 52-inch overall length. The Showvigor example states no handle length.
Which of these shovels fits in a car trunk?
The Showvigor example is described as portable and compact, built to ride in a car trunk for unexpected snowfall. The other three listings state no trunk or storage size.
More mowing guides
- 20v vs 40v Snow Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?
- Poly vs Metal Snow Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?
- Snow Blower vs Snow Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?
- Best Two Handed Snow Shovel (2026): 5 Picks Compared
If you clear snow with a machine as well, see our snow blower vs snow shovel comparison.




