Sand vs Cartridge Pool Filter: Which One Should You Buy?
Two sand filters compared by pool size, flow rate and valve settings, with no cartridge filter in the listings.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Aqua Joe 20 lb Pool Filter SandView on Amazon - 2
INTEX Krystal Clear 3View on Amazon - 3
INTEX Krystal Clear 2View on Amazon - 4
AQUASTRONG Sand Filter Pump for Above Ground Pool with TimerView on Amazon - 5
XtremepowerUS 16" Sand Filter Pump for Above Ground SwimmingView on Amazon - 6
VEVOR Sand Filter Pump 12" 1/3 HP 3000 GPH Swimming PoolView on Amazon
A pool filter keeps the water clear, and the choice comes down to sand vs cartridge pool filter. The listings for this guide cover sand filters only, with no cartridge filter among them, so the comparison here runs between the sand filters in the data. Between those, the choice comes down to pool size and whether the pump comes with the filter: the smaller unit suits a smaller above-ground pool and brings its own pump, while the larger unit suits a larger pool and needs a separate pump.
Other machines to compare
Aqua Joe 20 lb Pool Filter SandCheck price on Amazon
INTEX Krystal Clear 3Check price on Amazon
INTEX Krystal Clear 2Check price on Amazon
AQUASTRONG Sand Filter Pump for Above Ground Pool with TimerCheck price on Amazon
XtremepowerUS 16" Sand Filter Pump for Above Ground SwimmingCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Sand Filter Pump 12" 1/3 HP 3000 GPH Swimming PoolCheck price on Amazon
AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.
Sand vs cartridge pool filter: what the listings show
The listings give two sand filters and no cartridge filter. The table below compares them on the figures the makers state: pool size, flow rate, valve settings, sand capacity and pump.
| Filter | Pool size | Flow rate | Valve | Sand capacity | Pump |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AQUASTRONG Sand Filter Pump | Up to 9,000 gallons | 2,500 GPH | 6-way | 50 lbs | Included, 1/2 HP |
| XtremepowerUS Sand Filter System | Up to 25,200 gallons | 2,520 GPH | 7-way | 175 lbs | Not included |
No cartridge filter appears in the listings for this guide, so the table covers the two sand filters only. The rest of this guide compares those two on the figures above.
The two sand filters side by side
The AQUASTRONG unit pairs a 1/2 HP pump with a 12-inch sand filter in one package. The pump moves 2,500 GPH, with a system flow rate of 2,000 GPH, for pools up to 9,000 gallons. The 6-way valve covers Filter, Waste, Closed, Backwash, Recirculate and Rinse, and the maker states to stop the pump before switching valve position. A 24-hour programmable timer offers 9 settings from 2 to 24 hours, and the tank holds 50 lbs of sand, equal to 1.5 lbs of filter balls. Three 1.5 and 1.25-inch hose adapters with clamps and a five-piece 1.5-inch adapter conversion kit fit above-ground pools, and the unit carries a two-year warranty.
The XtremepowerUS unit is a 19-inch sand filter for above-ground and inground pools up to 25,200 gallons, with a filtration flow rate of up to 2,520 GPH. The 7-way valve covers Filter, Backwash, Winter, Re-Circulate, Closed, Rinse and Waste, and the tank holds 175 lbs of media sand. The tank measures 19 inches wide by 19 inches long by 36.6 inches high, with a 1.5-inch main internal pipe, a built-in drain and a pressure gauge. The pump is not included, and a pump is required.
How to choose between the two
Start with pool size: the AQUASTRONG suits pools up to 9,000 gallons, while the XtremepowerUS suits pools up to 25,200 gallons. Then check the pump: the AQUASTRONG brings a 1/2 HP pump and a timer, while the XtremepowerUS needs a separate pump. Sand capacity follows the same split, 50 lbs against 175 lbs, and the valve gives 6 settings on the AQUASTRONG against 7 on the XtremepowerUS, with Winter on the larger unit. The AQUASTRONG carries a two-year warranty; the XtremepowerUS warranty is not stated.
Running and cleaning a sand filter
Both filters clean by backwashing through the valve: set the valve to Backwash, then to Rinse, and return it to Filter. The AQUASTRONG valve also offers Waste and Recirculate, and the XtremepowerUS valve adds a Winter setting. Stop the pump before switching valve position, as the AQUASTRONG maker states. The AQUASTRONG timer automates filtration cycles on 9 settings from 2 to 24 hours, and the XtremepowerUS drain simplifies winterizing and servicing. Watch the pressure gauge on the XtremepowerUS tank, since the maker includes it with the tank.
FAQ: mowing large lots
Which sand filter fits my pool size?
The AQUASTRONG suits pools up to 9,000 gallons, and the XtremepowerUS suits pools up to 25,200 gallons. Check your pool volume against those figures before ordering, and remember the XtremepowerUS needs a separate pump.
Does the XtremepowerUS filter include a pump?
No. The pump is not included, and a pump is required. The AQUASTRONG is the filter here that includes a pump, a 1/2 HP unit with a 24-hour timer.
What do the valve settings do?
The AQUASTRONG 6-way valve offers Filter, Waste, Closed, Backwash, Recirculate and Rinse. The XtremepowerUS 7-way valve offers Filter, Backwash, Winter, Re-Circulate, Closed, Rinse and Waste. Stop the pump before switching valve position.
How much sand does each filter hold?
The AQUASTRONG holds 50 lbs of sand, equal to 1.5 lbs of filter balls. The XtremepowerUS holds 175 lbs of media sand. Match the sand load to the filter you buy, since the two tanks take different amounts.
What warranty comes with these filters?
The AQUASTRONG carries a two-year warranty. The XtremepowerUS warranty is not stated. Check the warranty terms before ordering if coverage matters to you.




