Solar vs Winter Pool Cover: Which One Should You Buy?
A solar cover heats pool water and cuts evaporation during swim season, while a winter cover closes the pool for the off-season; four solar covers compared by size and thickness.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 32 x 16 ft9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
Robelle 20 x 40 ft Winter Pool Cover for Inground Pools9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Real Relax 16 mil Solar Pool Cover9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 40 x 20 ftView on Amazon - 5
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 28 x 14 ftView on Amazon - 6
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 32 x 16 ft 16 Mil Pool Bubble CoverView on Amazon - 7
VEVOR Solar Pool CoverView on Amazon - 8
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 36 x 16 ftView on Amazon - 9
VINGLI 14x28ft Solar Pool Cover 12mil Rectangle BlueView on Amazon
A pool that sits warm through swim season and a pool that sits closed through the cold months need different covers, and solar vs winter pool cover is the choice between heating the water while you swim and closing the pool for the off-season. A solar cover floats on the water, soaks up sun and cuts evaporation while the pool stays open, while a winter cover goes on when swimming ends and stays on until spring. No winter cover is featured in the gear below, so the covers compared here are all solar covers, and the pick is simple: choose a solar cover for the swim season and a winter cover when you close the pool.
Other machines to compare
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 40 x 20 ftCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 28 x 14 ftCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 32 x 16 ft 16 Mil Pool Bubble CoverCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Solar Pool CoverCheck price on Amazon
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover 36 x 16 ftCheck price on Amazon
VINGLI 14x28ft Solar Pool Cover 12mil Rectangle BlueCheck price on Amazon
AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.
Solar vs winter pool cover: what each one does
A solar cover is a floating blanket that sits on the water while the pool is open. The covers below absorb heat from the sun during the day, and their bubble design cuts evaporation while keeping leaves and debris out of the water. A winter cover is the off-season cover: it goes on when the pool closes for the cold months and comes off when the pool reopens. The choice follows the calendar: a solar cover for the swim season, a winter cover for the months the pool sits unused. See the best winter pool cover picks for the off-season side of this choice.
What a solar cover does in season
Heat is the first job. The VEVOR cover states a water temperature increase of 8-15°C depending on conditions, and the Sun2Solar cover states a rise of up to 15 degrees from the sun. The VINGLI cover absorbs heat through its bubbles during the day and releases heat into the pool, and the Sun2Solar cover retains warmth long after the sun sets. The second job is evaporation: all four covers state a 95% cut in water evaporation, which cuts the need for added water. The Sun2Solar and Intex covers state that it also cuts chemical use. The third job is debris: each cover keeps leaves and debris out of the water, which cuts cleaning work. A solar cover earns its place while the pool is in use, and it comes off when the pool closes.
What a winter cover does in the off-season
A winter cover closes the pool for the months nobody swims. It goes on at the end of the swim season and stays on until the pool reopens, keeping the water covered while the pool sits unused. No winter cover is in the gear below, so this guide states no thickness, size or material figure for winter covers and compares the solar covers on their stated figures instead. If the pool is about to close for the season, the winter cover is the pick; if the pool is open and in use, the solar cover is the pick.
The gear: solar covers compared
The four solar covers below are listed in ranked order, from the thickest stated material and the fullest stated figures to the narrowest fit. All four state a 95% cut in evaporation, so size, thickness and fit separate them. See the best solar pool cover picks for more covers in this category.
| Cover | Size | Thickness | Evaporation cut | Temperature rise |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VEVOR Solar Pool Cover | 40 x 20 ft, rectangle | 16 mil | Up to 95% | 8-15°C |
| Sun2Solar Blue Solar Cover | 20 x 40 ft, rectangle | 12 mil | Up to 95% | Up to 15 degrees |
| VINGLI Solar Pool Cover | 14 x 28 ft, rectangle | 12 mil | 95% | Not stated |
| Intex 28014E Solar Pool Cover | 16 ft, round | Not stated | 95% | Not stated |
VEVOR Solar Pool Cover, 40 x 20 ft. The VEVOR cover is a 16 mil PE solar blanket sized 40 x 20 ft for rectangular pools, inground or above ground. Its closed bubble design is stated to prevent up to 95% of water evaporation, and the maker lists a water temperature increase of 8-15°C depending on conditions. The 16 mil PE material is stated to resist tearing and to hold up under sun without fading or warping, and the cover can be cut to fit any pool shape. The maker recommends use where chlorine stays below 2.5 ppm and pH above 7.2. It weighs 59.06 pounds.
Sun2Solar Blue Solar Cover, 20 x 40 ft. The Sun2Solar cover is a 12 mil rectangular cover sized 20 x 40 ft for inground and above ground pools. The maker lists a water temperature rise of up to 15 degrees from the sun, heat retained overnight, and evaporation reduced by up to 95%, which also cuts chemical use and the need for added water. The cover has extra overlap for easy installation and removal and can be trimmed to fit around protrusions. It stops leaves and debris from entering the pool, which cuts cleaning work.
VINGLI Solar Pool Cover, 14 x 28 ft. The VINGLI cover is a 12 mil rectangular cover sized 14 x 28 ft, with a bubble core that traps heat. The maker lists a 95% cut in evaporation and heavy-duty material with strong welded seams. The cover is easy to cut with scissors for irregular pool shapes, and the bubble side goes down when in use. The maker recommends using it with a VINGLI pool cover reel, which makes the cover easier to put on and take off.
Intex 28014E Solar Pool Cover, 16 ft round. The Intex cover is a round solar cover for 16-foot round Easy Set and metal frame pools. Air bubbles absorb and transfer sun heat into the pool water, and the maker lists a 95% reduction in water evaporation. The cover lays flat on top of the pool and keeps debris, leaves and trash out while reducing chemical consumption. It weighs 1.0 pounds, and no manufacturer warranty is stated for this cover.
Match the cover to the pool
Size comes first. The VEVOR cover is 40 x 20 ft, the Sun2Solar cover is 20 x 40 ft, the VINGLI cover is 14 x 28 ft, and the Intex cover fits 16-foot round pools. Measure the pool before ordering, and match the cover shape to the pool shape: the three rectangular covers suit rectangular pools, and the Intex cover suits a round pool. Three of the covers can be cut or trimmed to fit: the VEVOR cover can be cut to fit any pool shape, the Sun2Solar cover can be trimmed around protrusions, and the VINGLI cover can be cut with scissors for irregular shapes. Thickness is the second check: the VEVOR cover states 16 mil PE, while the Sun2Solar and VINGLI covers state 12 mil. The VEVOR cover weighs 59.06 pounds and the Intex cover weighs 1.0 pounds, so check the weight against what the person handling the cover can lift.
Safety
A solar cover floats on the water and is not a safety cover, so never treat it as a barrier. Keep children and pets away from the pool when the cover is on, and take the cover fully off before anyone swims. Store the cover where it stays out of the way when it is not on the pool.
FAQ: mowing large lots
Can a solar cover stay on the pool all winter?
No. A solar cover is for the swim season, when the pool is open and in use. When the pool closes for the cold months, take the solar cover off and put a winter cover on instead.
How much evaporation does a solar cover cut?
All four covers here state a 95% cut in water evaporation. The VEVOR and Sun2Solar covers state up to 95%, and the VINGLI and Intex covers state 95%.
How much warmer does the water get with a solar cover?
The VEVOR cover states a water temperature increase of 8-15°C depending on conditions, and the Sun2Solar cover states a rise of up to 15 degrees from the sun. No temperature rise figure is stated for the VINGLI or Intex covers.
Can I cut a solar cover to fit my pool?
Yes, for three of the covers here. The VEVOR cover can be cut to fit any pool shape, the Sun2Solar cover can be trimmed to fit around protrusions, and the VINGLI cover can be cut with scissors for irregular shapes.
Which thickness should I choose, 12 mil or 16 mil?
The covers that state a thickness give 12 mil or 16 mil. The VEVOR cover states 16 mil PE with tear resistance and no fading or warping under sun, while the Sun2Solar and VINGLI covers state 12 mil. Thickness is one check among size, fit and the evaporation figure, so match all of them to the pool.




