Tow Behind Aerator vs Aerator Shoes: Which One Should You Buy?
A tow-behind aerator covers large lawns behind a tractor, while aerator shoes suit small patches on foot in this guide.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Brinly PA-482BH-A2 Tow Behind Plug Aerator with Universal9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Leweio Pre-Assembled Lawn Aerator Shoes with Adjustable Strap9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Craftsman 40 Inch Tow Behind Lawn Plug Aerator with 249.7/10View on Amazon - 4
48" Spike Aerator Tow BehindView on Amazon - 5
Lawn Aerator Shoes Pre-AssembledView on Amazon - 6
Brinly Tow Behind Combination Aerator Spreader with WeightView on Amazon - 7
Suchtale 40-Inch Tow Behind Spike Aerator with GalvanizedView on Amazon - 8
Brinly Tow Behind Spike Aerator with Double Tow Bar and 3DView on Amazon - 9
Titan 3 FT Tow-Behind Drum Spike Aerator Holds up to 25 GalView on Amazon
A tow-behind aerator wins on a large lawn, and aerator shoes win on a small patch. A tow-behind unit pulls behind a tractor and covers a wide path in each pass, while the shoes strap to your boots and poke holes as you walk. This guide answers the tow behind aerator vs aerator shoes question, then compares 4 tow-behind aerators in the gear section below.
Other machines to compare
48" Spike Aerator Tow BehindCheck price on Amazon
Lawn Aerator Shoes Pre-AssembledCheck price on Amazon
Brinly Tow Behind Combination Aerator Spreader with WeightCheck price on Amazon
Suchtale 40-Inch Tow Behind Spike Aerator with GalvanizedCheck price on Amazon
Brinly Tow Behind Spike Aerator with Double Tow Bar and 3DCheck price on Amazon
Titan 3 FT Tow-Behind Drum Spike Aerator Holds up to 25 GalCheck price on Amazon
AcreMowerLab earns a commission when you shop through links here. It never changes your price. Affiliate disclosure.
Tow behind aerator vs aerator shoes: how they compare
| Tool | Best for | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Tow-behind aerator | Large lawns, gardens and farms behind a tractor | Needs a tractor with a hitch |
| Aerator shoes | Small patches walked on foot | Slow past a small patch |
| Plug aerator | Compacted soil, cores pulled out | Tray weight helps reach full depth |
| Spike aerator | Holes in dry, hard ground | No cores pulled out |
The 4 listings here are all tow-behind units, so the gear section below compares those 4, and the shoes side is covered in the section on what aerator shoes do. Width and tray weight are two stated figures that set the tow-behind models apart.
The gear: 4 tow-behind aerators, widest first
The gear section ranks the 4 tow-behind aerators by stated width, widest first. All 4 state penetration up to 2 in deep, so depth does not split them.
YINTATECH 48 Inch Plug Aerator
One of the two 48 in units here, the YINTATECH 48 Inch Plug Aerator, is a plug aerator with 32 galvanized steel tines in 6 sets of star-shaped tines, and it states penetration up to 2 in deep. The weight tray takes concrete blocks for depth, the frame is all steel, and the unit weighs 72.75 lb with 10 in pneumatic tires, a cantilever transport handle and a control lever for crossing driveways and sidewalks. It connects by universal hitch to lawn tractors, zero-turn mowers and ATVs, and the stated dimensions are 40.0 in by 48.0 in by 15.0 in.
PPOLB 48 Inch Spike Aerator
The PPOLB 48 Inch Spike Aerator is also 48 in wide, with 12 star-shaped spike discs that state penetration up to 2 in deep. Its tray holds up to 280 lbs of added weight, the most stated here, and the frame is galvanized steel with a universal hitch and a lever that switches between transport and working mode. The unit weighs 44.64 lb and measures 53.94 in by 10.83 in by 4.92 in. Note the listing mixes terms: the title says spike, while the bullets call it a plug aerator, so read the tine description rather than the title.
Doniks 40 Inch Tow Behind Plug Aerator
The Doniks 40 Inch Tow Behind Plug Aerator is 40 in wide, with 10 steel tine stars, each with an 8 in diameter and 10 sharp spikes, stating penetration up to 2 in deep. Its tray holds up to 130 lbs of added weight, the bracket is 6mm thick steel, and the unit has pneumatic tyres, a cantilevered transport handle and a control lever. The listing states a connection to any brand of tractor. Note the listing mixes terms: the title says plug, while the bullets call it a spike aerator.
VEVOR 32 Inch Tow Behind Spike Aerator
The VEVOR 32 Inch Tow Behind Spike Aerator is the narrowest here at 32 in wide, and its tray holds up to 100 lbs of added weight. The frame is high-strength steel with a fully welded frame and reinforced hardware, the tray has folded edges and strap slots, and a socket tool and wrench come with it for assembly. The unit weighs 27.56 lb and measures 32.68 in by 32.28 in by 11.81 in. Note the listing mixes terms: the title says spike, while the bullets call the tines coring tines, so read the tine description rather than the title.
Plug or spike tines
The listings split on tine type, but the titles and the tine descriptions do not line up. The YINTATECH listing calls its unit a plug aerator with star-shaped tines, the Doniks listing calls its unit a plug aerator in the title and a spike aerator in the bullets, with steel tine stars that carry sharp spikes, and the PPOLB listing calls its unit a spike aerator in the title and a plug aerator in the bullets, with star-shaped spike discs. The VEVOR listing calls its unit a spike aerator in the title and states coring tines in the bullets. Read the tine description rather than the title when the type matters. A plug aerator pulls cores from the lawn; a spike aerator pokes holes and leaves the soil in place.
Width and weight tray
Widths here run 32 in to 48 in. The YINTATECH and PPOLB models are 48 in wide, the Doniks is 40 in, and the VEVOR is 32 in. A wider unit covers more ground per pass. The trays hold added weight for depth: 280 lbs on the PPOLB, 130 lbs on the Doniks, 100 lbs on the VEVOR, and the YINTATECH tray takes concrete blocks with no weight stated. Add weight only up to the tray limit the listing states.
What aerator shoes do
Aerator shoes strap to your boots and poke holes as you walk the lawn. No shoe model is listed in the gear section, since the listings here are all tow-behind units. Shoes suit a small patch or a tight spot a tractor cannot reach, and they need no hitch, no tray weight and no storage space beyond a shelf. On a large lawn they are slow, since each step covers only the width of a boot.
Safety
Wear eye protection and sturdy shoes, and keep children, pets and bystanders away from the work area. Check the ground for sticks, stones and buried lines before you start, and follow the manual for the tractor and the aerator. Add tray weight only up to the limit the listing states, and lift the tines before crossing a driveway or sidewalk, using the transport lever where the unit has one.
FAQ: mowing large lots
Should I buy a tow-behind aerator or aerator shoes?
A tow-behind aerator suits a large lawn behind a tractor, since it covers a 32 in to 48 in path per pass. Aerator shoes suit a small patch walked on foot, since they need no hitch or tray weight. Pick the tool against the size of the lawn.
How deep do these aerators penetrate?
All 4 listings state penetration up to 2 in deep. The YINTATECH, VEVOR, PPOLB and Doniks models each state 2 in, with tray weight added for depth where the listing states a tray limit.
Do tow-behind aerators need a tractor?
They tow behind a tractor or a similar tow vehicle, per the listings: the YINTATECH connects to lawn tractors, zero-turn mowers and ATVs, the PPOLB to lawn tractors, UTVs and ATVs, and the Doniks to any brand of tractor. The VEVOR tows behind a lawn tractor or riding mower. 3 of the 4 state a universal hitch, per the listings.
What is the difference between a plug aerator and a spike aerator?
A plug aerator pulls cores of soil out of the lawn, while a spike aerator pokes holes without removing soil. The titles here do not line up with the tine descriptions: the Doniks title says plug while its bullets describe spike stars, the PPOLB title says spike while its bullets call it a plug aerator, and the VEVOR title says spike while its bullets state coring tines. Read the tine description rather than the title.
How much weight can the tray hold?
The PPOLB tray holds up to 280 lbs, the Doniks tray up to 130 lbs, and the VEVOR tray up to 100 lbs. The YINTATECH tray takes concrete blocks with no weight stated. Add weight only up to the limit the listing states.




